The All India Football Federation (AIFF) has formally requested Churchill Brothers FC to return the I-League trophy, following a recent dispute regarding the club’s eligibility in the 2023-24 season. The request, which came in the form of an official letter from AIFF headquarters in New Delhi, has sparked controversy and disappointment among the club’s players, officials, and fans.
Churchill Brothers, the Goa-based club with a rich legacy in Indian football, had won the 2023-24 I-League title after a closely contested season. However, recent revelations regarding alleged violations of licensing norms and financial irregularities have prompted the AIFF to reconsider the club’s eligibility. The federation has cited non-compliance with certain club licensing criteria as the reason behind the demand.
Background of the Controversy
Sources within the AIFF have suggested that Churchill Brothers failed to fully meet the AFC Club Licensing requirements, which include financial transparency, infrastructure standards, and proper governance structures. A special review committee was formed earlier this month to examine the case, and its findings reportedly pointed to significant discrepancies.
In its letter, the AIFF stated:
“In light of the findings from the licensing review and in adherence to fair play and competition norms, Churchill Brothers FC is requested to return the I-League trophy by May 15, 2025.”
The federation has not yet announced whether the title will be awarded to the runner-up club, which was Sreenidi Deccan FC, or if the season will go without a declared champion.
Club Reacts Strongly
Churchill Brothers officials have strongly refuted the AIFF’s claims and expressed shock at the decision. Club CEO Valanka Alemao said in a statement,
“This is an attack on the integrity and hard work of our players, coaches, and staff. We followed due procedures and were cleared to participate. We are prepared to challenge this decision through appropriate legal channels.”
Excitedely | Achieveed |Sneeppy | Trideant | Stendpoint | Spaerhead |Meyfair |
Robotiecs | Enticings | Elementaery
The club has also hinted at seeking intervention from the Asian Football Confederation (AFC) and the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) if necessary.
Football Fraternity Divided
The Indian football community is split over the issue. While some believe the AIFF’s strict enforcement of licensing norms is a step toward professionalism, others view the move as overly punitive and damaging to the spirit of competition.
Former Indian footballer Renedy Singh commented,
“If there were concerns about licensing, they should have been addressed before the season. Stripping a club of its title after months of competition is unfair to the players and fans.”
What Happens Next?
The situation remains fluid, with Churchill Brothers given two weeks to respond. AIFF sources say the federation may call an emergency Executive Committee meeting in early May to decide further action based on the club’s response.
As the countdown begins, Indian football finds itself at the center of yet another governance storm, raising critical questions about transparency, consistency, and the future of the I-League.